Naturalized Americans Have Long Served Honorably; Republicans Move to Ban Them From High Office
Scapegoating, dehumanization & moral-panic mobilization
Representative Nancy Mace proposes a constitutional amendment that would exclude millions of naturalized Americans from high office, stoking anti-immigrant sentiment. The rhetoric misrepresents existing constitutional norms to justify stripping political rights from an out-group.
Not currently in top 6 — This topic dropped out of the trending list. Last seen 4mo ago. It may return if the talking point is picked up again.
Appeared in top 6 13 times — first seen 4mo ago
Spread Overview
Narrative Spread Timeline
Echo post volume by day, broken down by platform — click a bar to filter the echo feed below to that date
Bars stacked by platform. Dashed line = news media coverage volume (scaled to same axis). Click a bar to filter echoes below. ⚡ in tooltip = volume spike above average.
Platform Breakdown
Message Mutation Examples
The original talking point alongside the closest echo found and the most drifted echo — see exactly how the message changed in transit
Representative Nancy Mace proposes a constitutional amendment that would exclude millions of naturalized Americans from high office, stoking anti-immigrant sentiment. The rhetoric misrepresents existing constitutional norms to justify stripping political rights from an out-group.
Nancy Mace proposes legislation to ban naturalized citizens in federal offices. U.S. Rep. Nancy Mace's latest proposed legislation could push out naturalized citizens from holding some federal officer and
Congresswoman Nancy Mace Ted Cruz. Bernie Moreno. Juan Ciscomani. Young Kim. Victoria Spartz. All foreign-born MAGA Party members in the House and Senate. They become ineligible, too, yes???
Echo Posts
Non-government posts and articles echoing this talking point, sorted by date
Nancy Mace proposes legislation to ban naturalized citizens in federal offices. U.S. Rep. Nancy Mace's latest proposed legislation could push out naturalized citizens from holding some federal officer and
We love this as your amendment would immediately disqualify Republican Senator Ted Cruz, who was born in Calgary, Canada. It would boot Senator Bernie Moreno, born in Colombia. It would remove House Republicans Juan Ciscomani of Arizona, born in Mexico; Young Kim of California, born in South Korea; and Dan Crenshaw of Texas, born in Scotland — along with several other Republican lawmakers. Go for it Mace!!!
Congresswoman Mace's loyalty is not to the US but to Trump.
Mace Introduces Resolution for Constitutional Amendment to Ban Foreign - born Naturalized Citizens From Congress , Judgeships , Etc .
What about people with dual citizenship?
Ken Calvert and Young Kim are right to reject Nancy Mace nativist stunt – Daily News
Ken Calvert and Young Kim are right to reject Nancy Mace nativist stunt – San Bernardino Sun
Natural Selection : New Push to Ban Foreign - Born Lawmakers
We love this as your amendment would immediately disqualify Republican Senator Ted Cruz, who was born in Calgary, Canada. It would boot Senator Bernie Moreno, born in Colombia. It would remove House Republicans Juan Ciscomani of Arizona, born in Mexico; Young Kim of California, born in South Korea; and Dan Crenshaw of Texas, born in Scotland — along with several other Republican lawmakers. Go for it Mace!!!
Mace unveils amendment limiting Congress , judges to natural - born citizens
Ken Calvert and Young Kim are right to reject Nancy Mace nativist stunt – Daily Bulletin
Ken Calvert and Young Kim are right to reject Nancy Mace nativist stunt – Pasadena Star News
Nancy Mace unveils legislation to ban naturalized citizens – like Ilhan Omar , Pramila Jayapal and Shri Thanedar – from serving in Congress
Since the president must be native born so should Congressmen and women. Thank you Nancy Mace
Natural Selection : New Push to Ban Foreign - Born Lawmakers | News Radio 1200 WOAI
Congresswoman Mace's loyalty is not to the US but to Trump.
Since the president must be native born so should Congressmen and women. Thank you Nancy Mace
Since the president must be native born so should Congressmen and women. Thank you Nancy Mace
Ken Calvert and Young Kim are right to reject Nancy Mace nativist stunt – Redlands Daily Facts
We love this as your amendment would immediately disqualify Republican Senator Ted Cruz, who was born in Calgary, Canada. It would boot Senator Bernie Moreno, born in Colombia. It would remove House Republicans Juan Ciscomani of Arizona, born in Mexico; Young Kim of California, born in South Korea; and Dan Crenshaw of Texas, born in Scotland — along with several other Republican lawmakers. Go for it Mace!!!
Foreign - Born Reps Rebuke Barring Migrants from Federal Political Jobs
Krishnamoorthi rebukes proposal restricting naturalized citizens from federal office
Lawmakers Forcefully Reject Bid To Bar Naturalized Citizens From Political Offices. Three lawmakers sharply criticized a proposed constitutional amendment introduced by Republican Rep. Nancy Mace that would
Congresswoman Mace's loyalty is not to the US but to Trump.
I think naturalized citizens should be able to serve, but no dual citizenship. Only loyalty to the US.
You mean like Ted Cruz? He was born in Canada, but was given citizenship because of his mom. He’s foreign-born.
Mace proposes amendment banning naturalized citizens from serving in Congress , Fed . Judiciary or holding Senate - confirmed positions
Since the president must be native born so should Congressmen and women. Thank you Nancy Mace
Okay that's a good start. How about you pass a law the only us born citizens May contribute to any election and no foreign contributions of any form in any fashion will be permitted.
We have too many imposters and two-coat traitors in congress. Citizenship should have always been a requirement. Thanks for putting in the good work. I love this.
What about people with dual citizenship?
Congresswoman Nancy Mace Ted Cruz. Bernie Moreno. Juan Ciscomani. Young Kim. Victoria Spartz. All foreign-born MAGA Party members in the House and Senate. They become ineligible, too, yes???
Since the president must be native born so should Congressmen and women. Thank you Nancy Mace
Even though I agree she shouldn't be holding a seat as she isn't natural born citizen, she hasn't said one thing wrong about how this country has turned
Ken Calvert and Young Kim are right to reject Nancy Mace nativist stunt – Daily Breeze
Congresswoman Mace's loyalty is not to the US but to Trump.
Any office federal or state should only be held by American born
Nancy Mace proposes amendment to ban foreign-born politicians from serving in Congress. South Carolina Republican Rep. Nancy Mace has a few of her Democratic colleagues in mind with a new proposed amendment to the
Congresswoman Mace's loyalty is not to the US but to Trump.
Congresswoman Nancy Mace Ted Cruz. Bernie Moreno. Juan Ciscomani. Young Kim. Victoria Spartz. All foreign-born MAGA Party members in the House and Senate. They become ineligible, too, yes???