Noncitizen Voting Is Rare; Republicans Push ‘SAVE America Act’ to Restrict Ballots
Voter-eligibility manipulation & roll purges
Extensive research shows virtually no evidence of widespread noncitizen voting, yet Republicans claim it is a crisis to justify new documentation rules. The coordinated push reframes voter suppression as ‘election integrity,’ a narrative that risks disenfranchising naturalized citizens, students, and communities of color.
Not currently in top 6 — This topic dropped out of the trending list. Last seen 1mo ago. It may return if the talking point is picked up again.
Appeared in top 6 66 times — first seen 7mo ago — currently on its 10th wave (it went quiet and resurfaced before)
Spread Overview
Narrative Spread Timeline
Echo post volume by day, broken down by platform — click a bar to filter the echo feed below to that date
Bars stacked by platform. Click a bar to filter echoes below. ⚡ in tooltip = volume spike above average.
Platform Breakdown
Message Mutation Examples
The original talking point alongside the closest echo found and the most drifted echo — see exactly how the message changed in transit
Extensive research shows virtually no evidence of widespread noncitizen voting, yet Republicans claim it is a crisis to justify new documentation rules. The coordinated push reframes voter suppression as ‘election integrity,’ a narrative that risks disenfranchising naturalized citizens, students, and communities of color.
Pass the SAVE America Act (S. 3752). This commonsense legislation strengthens election integrity- requiring voter ID for federal elections and proof of citizenship for voter registration. @JDVance @realDonaldTrump @JohnCornyn @SenTedCruz
Voter ID and what’s required by Save Act are completely different. Stop listening to the liars.
Echo Posts
Non-government posts and articles echoing this talking point, sorted by date
Pass the SAVE America Act (S. 3752). This commonsense legislation strengthens election integrity- requiring voter ID for federal elections and proof of citizenship for voter registration. @JDVance @realDonaldTrump @JohnCornyn @SenTedCruz
Republicans face a growing conundrum on the ‘SAVE America Act’. The GOP appears stuck between a rock and a hard place when it comes to the legislation the party has dubbed the “SAVE America
@elonmusk Many states require photo ID, but the Save Act says that isn't good enough. They want passports or birth certificates. I had to prove I was a citizen to get a Real ID. That should be more than sufficient to vote.
What Is the SAVE Act? Inside Trump's Voting Bill. The Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act is framed by the White House as part of a broader "SAVE America Act" agenda
Today we already HAVE voter ID. Republicans are LYING when they claim the SAVE Act is about voter ID.
The SAVE Act would disenfranchise 10 to 20 million US citizens as the IDs allowed are so restrictive. (The Brennon Center) All for a problem that does not exist, there is no evidence of widespread or significant non citizen voting that has tipped a federal election. It is a lie told so often it has become a mass delusion.
Democrats block GOP voter ID push despite claiming support, sparking backlash. Senate Democrats opposed a standalone voter ID measure, citing concerns over other parts of the SAVE America Act
Republicans face a growing conundrum on the 'SAVE America Act'. The GOP appears stuck between a rock and a hard place when it comes to the legislation the party has dubbed the "SAVE America Act."
Wanting voter ID and supporting the SAVE Act are two different things.
Republicans defend, Democrats vilify GOP voter ID bill. As a marathon debate over the SAVE America Act continues in the U.S. Senate, Republicans and Democrats are sparring over whether the voter ID bill would st
@elonmusk The save act invalidates millions of legal voters. Which includes married couples and adopted children and transgender people. You already are required to show valid id when you vote. But restricting it to show birth certificate or a passport along with your id it is fraud too.
SAVE America Act: Republicans launching voting bill debate in Senate. President Donald Trump is urging Congress to get the SAVE America Act passed as Republicans prepare to begin talks on the Senate floor about the legislation
SAVE America Act: Republicans launching voting bill debate in Senate. President Donald Trump is urging Congress to get the SAVE America Act passed as Republicans prepare to begin talks on the Senate floor about the legislation
As Trump pressures Congress on the SAVE America Act, states push their own.... As push from Republicans and Donald Trump to pass theSAVE America Acthave stalled in Congress,
Wanting voter ID and supporting the SAVE Act are two different things.
Here’s what’s in Trump’s SAVE America Act. President Trump’s push to pass the Safeguard American Voter Eligibility (SAVE) America Act is taking center stage this week in the Senate, where it faces an uphill battle amid unified Democratic
What's in Trump's SAVE America Act. President Donald Trump's push to pass the Safeguard American Voter Eligibility (SAVE) America Act is taking center stage this week in the Senate, where it faces an uphill battle amid unified Democratic opposition
BS nonsense. The Save Act proposes a solution to a nonexistent problem while simultaneously disenfranchising millions of Americans, particularly women who changed their names after getting married. Both the CATO Institute and Heritage Foundation (conservative organizations) say that voter fraud is miniscule. Some Facts: Data from the Heritage Foundation Study (1999-2023) 77 cases of non-citizens successfully casting a ballot over 24 years. 10 cases of undocumented immigrants who voted 1 billion+ ballots Estimated total votes cast in the U.S. (1999-2023) 0.00000764% Minuscule Percentage of All Votes. The Bottom Line: Even using data from a conservative organization looking for fraud, the instances of non-citizens voting are statistically microscopic. So why are they making it difficult for hard working Americans to vote… unless that it their objective?
OPINION: Breaking Down the SAVE America Act: Photo ID. With the midterm elections rapidly approaching and polls showing Republicans in serious trouble with voters, they have become frantic to pass the SAVE America Act. Twenty-five House members are now promising to vote no on everything until the act is passed
There is a huge difference between voter ID and what is in the SAVE Act.
Voter ID isn't suppression, it builds confidence. This week, Congress continues to debate the SAVE America Act, designed to strengthen voter ID and proof-of-citizenship requirements nationwide. Back in February, the U.S. House passed it 218-213 largely along
There’s a big difference between simply “voter id should be required” and the SAVE Act. We know you are intelligent enough to understand this contrast. WE ARE. Instead of blindly following the edict of Your Leader, listen to ALL your constituents and seek a compromise. You represent us ALL.
Voter ID and what’s required by Save Act are completely different. Stop listening to the liars.
The save is not about ID. Period. It is an attempt at voter suppression for taxpayers and it’s unconstitutional so do not confuse things. We already show ID and our elections are secure
Sure we support voter ID, but not the save act, they are not the same.
Showing an ID is not the only problem. The SAVE Act eliminates most mail in voting, requires a person to go in person to a registration office to register to vote, update their name or address instead of being able to do it all online, it allows for voter roll purges without notification that you've been purged, it would require people to purchase expensive proof of citizenship like passports or certified copies of birth certicates which could be considered an unconstitutional poll tax, and it would force married women, Native Americans and adoptees to jump through more hoops than necessary to exercise their constitutional right to vote. So please stop saying it's just about voter ID...it's so much more than that. And for those of you who don't believe it, a simple internet search will show you the truth.
Big difference between voter ID and the SAVE act.
The SAVE Act includes more than just voter ID. Read it.
Voter id, not the save act. 2 entirely different things.
The SAVE Act and wanting voter ID are not the same thing.
Wanting voter ID and supporting the SAVE Act are two different things.
Voter ID and the Save act are two different things.
The SAVE Act and wanting voter ID are not the same thing.
The SAVE Act and wanting voter ID are not the same thing.
Voter ID and the Save act are two different things.
There is a huge difference between voter ID and what is in the SAVE Act.
There’s a big difference between simply “voter id should be required” and the SAVE Act. We know you are intelligent enough to understand this contrast. WE ARE. Instead of blindly following the edict of Your Leader, listen to ALL your constituents and seek a compromise. You represent us ALL.
BS nonsense. The Save Act proposes a solution to a nonexistent problem while simultaneously disenfranchising millions of Americans, particularly women who changed their names after getting married. Both the CATO Institute and Heritage Foundation (conservative organizations) say that voter fraud is miniscule. Some Facts: Data from the Heritage Foundation Study (1999-2023) 77 cases of non-citizens successfully casting a ballot over 24 years. 10 cases of undocumented immigrants who voted 1 billion+ ballots Estimated total votes cast in the U.S. (1999-2023) 0.00000764% Minuscule Percentage of All Votes. The Bottom Line: Even using data from a conservative organization looking for fraud, the instances of non-citizens voting are statistically microscopic. So why are they making it difficult for hard working Americans to vote… unless that it their objective?
The save is not about ID. Period. It is an attempt at voter suppression for taxpayers and it’s unconstitutional so do not confuse things. We already show ID and our elections are secure
The save is not about ID. Period. It is an attempt at voter suppression for taxpayers and it’s unconstitutional so do not confuse things. We already show ID and our elections are secure
What in the SAVE America Act and why is it so important to Donald Trump ? | National Politics
I’m diving into the SAVE America Act. This isn’t about voter ID—it’s voter suppression, a cover for corruption, and disguised as immigration enforcement. Buckle up. — Diana Onyejiaka, U.S. Senate - TN https://t.co/lmPf1YdEbD
I don't have a problem with simple voter ID. The "Save America Act" is not just voter ID. It virtually eliminates mail-in voting. It has the federal government purge the states' voter rolls periodicly.. It makes it more difficult to vote. That's the definition of voter suppression. Call it whatever cynical name you like, but it's clearly VOTER SUPPRESSION!!! BTW the constitution gives pretty much everything related to elections and voting in the hands of the states. This is a dramatic federal overreach that tramples states rights.
@EdMarkey What is ridiculous about requiring photo ID to vote? PASS THE SAVE ACT NOW https://t.co/c3vmZChuGh
BS nonsense. The Save Act proposes a solution to a nonexistent problem while simultaneously disenfranchising millions of Americans, particularly women who changed their names after getting married. Both the CATO Institute and Heritage Foundation (conservative organizations) say that voter fraud is miniscule. Some Facts: Data from the Heritage Foundation Study (1999-2023) 77 cases of non-citizens successfully casting a ballot over 24 years. 10 cases of undocumented immigrants who voted 1 billion+ ballots Estimated total votes cast in the U.S. (1999-2023) 0.00000764% Minuscule Percentage of All Votes. The Bottom Line: Even using data from a conservative organization looking for fraud, the instances of non-citizens voting are statistically microscopic. So why are they making it difficult for hard working Americans to vote… unless that it their objective?
There’s a big difference between simply “voter id should be required” and the SAVE Act. We know you are intelligent enough to understand this contrast. WE ARE. Instead of blindly following the edict of Your Leader, listen to ALL your constituents and seek a compromise. You represent us ALL.
Commentary: Stop fighting voter ID. Start defining it.. COMMENTARY: Columnist Dana Dolan argues Democrats should reframe the SAVE Act debate by backing voter ID rules that expand access instead of restricting it
Voter ID and the Save act are two different things.
Voter ID and the Save act are two different things.
Voter ID and what’s required by Save Act are completely different. Stop listening to the liars.
Showing 50 of 4,954 total echoes.